Difference between revisions of "Patriarchy" - New World Encyclopedia

From New World Encyclopedia
m
(→‎Feminist view: reference)
Line 37: Line 37:
 
Human societies, whether they are ''ancient'', ''indigenous'' or ''modern industrial'', have been described in Anthropology in terms of either patriarchal or matriarchal systems. Between these polarities lie a number of social structures which include elements of both systems (see above under Patriarchy a discussion of the terms ''patrilinial'' and ''patrilocal'' ).  
 
Human societies, whether they are ''ancient'', ''indigenous'' or ''modern industrial'', have been described in Anthropology in terms of either patriarchal or matriarchal systems. Between these polarities lie a number of social structures which include elements of both systems (see above under Patriarchy a discussion of the terms ''patrilinial'' and ''patrilocal'' ).  
  
Anthropologist Donald Brown has listed patriarchy to be one of the "[[human universals]]" (Brown 1991, p. 137), which includes characteristics such as age gradation, personal hygiene, aesthetics, food sharing, rape, and other sociological aspects, implying that patriarchy is innate to the human condition. Margaret Mead has observed that "... all the claims so glibly made about societies ruled by women are nonsense. We have no reason to believe that they ever existed....Men have always been the leaders in public affairs and the final authorities at home."[http://www.cortsoft.com/mop/Books3.htm]
+
Anthropologist Donald Brown has listed patriarchy to be one of the "[[human universals]]" (Brown 1991, p. 137), which includes characteristics such as age gradation, personal hygiene, aesthetics, food sharing, rape, and other sociological aspects, implying that patriarchy is innate to the human condition. Margaret Mead has observed that "... all the claims so glibly made about societies ruled by women are nonsense. We have no reason to believe that they ever existed....Men have always been the leaders in public affairs and the final authorities at home."<ref>[http://www.cortsoft.com/mop/Books3.htm]</ref>
  
Societies have developed out of patriarchal cultures. Institutions of religion, education, commerce retain patriarchal practices.  In [[Muslim]] counties today, patriarchy in the form of divided roles between of women and men into the domestic and social spheres is distinctly visible. In [[European|Europe]] and [[Americas|America]] whose cultures are based on a [[Christianity|Christian]] model, political and religious power continues to exert a strong influence. The ideas of [[Age of Enlightenment]] philosophy, and [[Revolution]]ary movements including [[Feminism]] have brought about changes creating wider possibilities for both women and men. [[Marxist]] ideals support the advocacy of [[egalitarianism]] between the sexes, but these aspirations have been overtaken by authoritarian forms of political organisation in communist states. In [[China]], for example, where by law the [[National People's Congress]] is composed of an equal number of men and women.  There are, however, no women within the [[Politburo of the Communist Party of China]], the agency that actually rules China.  Prior to its dissolution, the [[Soviet Union]]'s [[Congress of People's Deputies]] likewise consisted of equal numbers of men and women. Its successor, the [[Duma]], which has governing authority, at present has only 35 woman deputies among the 450 members.[http://www.eng.yabloko.ru/Forums/Main/posts/1376.html]
+
Societies have developed out of patriarchal cultures. Institutions of religion, education, commerce retain patriarchal practices.  In [[Muslim]] counties today, patriarchy in the form of divided roles between of women and men into the domestic and social spheres is distinctly visible. In [[European|Europe]] and [[Americas|America]] whose cultures are based on a [[Christianity|Christian]] model, political and religious power continues to exert a strong influence. The ideas of [[Age of Enlightenment]] philosophy, and [[Revolution]]ary movements including [[Feminism]] have brought about changes creating wider possibilities for both women and men. [[Marxist]] ideals support the advocacy of [[egalitarianism]] between the sexes, but these aspirations have been overtaken by authoritarian forms of political organisation in communist states. In [[China]], for example, where by law the [[National People's Congress]] is composed of an equal number of men and women.  There are, however, no women within the [[Politburo of the Communist Party of China]], the agency that actually rules China.  Prior to its dissolution, the [[Soviet Union]]'s [[Congress of People's Deputies]] likewise consisted of equal numbers of men and women. Its successor, the [[Duma]], which has governing authority, at present has only 35 woman deputies among the 450 members.<ref>[http://www.eng.yabloko.ru/Forums/Main/posts/1376.html]</ref>
 
   
 
   
 
This longstanding thesis has raised political opposition.  The Modern Matriarchal Studies organization has held two conferences Luxembourg (2004) and San Marcos, Texas (2005) so as to redefine the term "matriarchy." [http://www.hagia.de/ www.hagia.de/] (hagia being derived from the [[Greek language|Greek]] hagios or "holy"}. Various chairs, called "priestesses" in the group's literature, conducted workshops and at the end of the conference declared that “International Matriarchal Politics stands against white supremacist patriarchal capitalist homogenization and the globalization of misery. It stands for egalitarianism, diversity and the economics of the heart. Many matriarchal societies still exist around the world and they propose an alternative, life affirming model to patriarchal raptor capitalism."[http://www.hagia.de/documents/declaration.pdf Societies of Peace Declaration (2005), 2-3]
 
This longstanding thesis has raised political opposition.  The Modern Matriarchal Studies organization has held two conferences Luxembourg (2004) and San Marcos, Texas (2005) so as to redefine the term "matriarchy." [http://www.hagia.de/ www.hagia.de/] (hagia being derived from the [[Greek language|Greek]] hagios or "holy"}. Various chairs, called "priestesses" in the group's literature, conducted workshops and at the end of the conference declared that “International Matriarchal Politics stands against white supremacist patriarchal capitalist homogenization and the globalization of misery. It stands for egalitarianism, diversity and the economics of the heart. Many matriarchal societies still exist around the world and they propose an alternative, life affirming model to patriarchal raptor capitalism."[http://www.hagia.de/documents/declaration.pdf Societies of Peace Declaration (2005), 2-3]
  
 
===Chinese Patriarchy===
 
===Chinese Patriarchy===
[[Mencius]] outlined the Three Subordinations. A woman was to be subordinate to her father in youth, her husband in maturity, and her son in old age.
+
[[Mencius]] outlined the Three Subordinations: A woman was to be subordinate to her father in youth, her husband in maturity, and her son in old age.
  
A cliche of classical texts, which is repeated throughout the tradition, is the familiar notion that men govern the outer world, while women govern the home.
+
Repeated throughout ancient Chinese tradition, the familiar notion that men govern the outer world, while women govern the home serves as a cliche of classical texts.
  
In the [[Han dynasty]], the female historian [[Ban Zhao]] wrote the [[Lessons for Women]], advice on how women should behave. She outlines the Four Virtues women must abide by, proper virtue, proper speech, proper countenance, proper merit. The "three subordinations and the four virtues" is a common four-character phrase throughout the imperial period.
+
In the [[Han dynasty]], the female historian [[Ban Zhao]] wrote the [[Lessons for Women]] to advise women how to behave. She outlined the Four Virtues women must abide by: proper virtue, proper speech, proper countenance, and proper merit. The "three subordinations and the four virtues" became a common four-character phrase throughout the imperial period.
  
As for the historical development of Chinese patriarchy, women's status was highest in the [[Tang dynasty]], when women played sports (polo) and were generally freer in fashion and conduct. Between the Tang and Song dynasties, a fad for little feet arose, and from the [[Song dynasty]] onwards [[footbinding]] became more and more common for the elite. In the Ming dynasty, a tradition of virtuous widowhood developed. Widows, even if widowed at a young age, would be expected not to remarry. Their virtuous names might be displayed on the arch at the entrance of the village.
+
As for the historical development of Chinese patriarchy, women's status was highest in the [[Tang dynasty]], when women played sports (polo) and were generally freer in fashion and conduct. Between the Tang and [[Song dynasty|Song dynasties]], a fad for little feet arose, and from the [[Song dynasty]] onwards [[footbinding]] became more and more common for the elite. In the [[Ming dynasty]], a tradition of virtuous widowhood developed. Widows, even if widowed at a young age, were expected to not remarry. If they remained widows, their virtuous names might be displayed on the arch at the entrance of the village.
  
Symptoms of patriarchy in 20th and 21st century China include the immense pressure on women to get married before the age of 30, and the incidence of [[female infanticide]] associated with China's [[one child policy]].  However, footbinding has been eradicated and trafficking in women in China has greatly reduced.
+
Symptoms of patriarchy in 20th and 21st century China include the immense pressure on women to get married before the age of 30 and the incidence of [[female infanticide]] associated with China's [[one child policy]].  However, footbinding has been eradicated and trafficking in women in China has greatly reduced.
  
 
==In gender studies==
 
==In gender studies==
 
In [[gender studies]], the word ''patriarchy'' often refers to a social organization marked by the supremacy of a male figure, group of male figures, or men in general. It is depicted as subordinating women, children, and those whose genders or bodies defy traditional man/woman categorization.
 
In [[gender studies]], the word ''patriarchy'' often refers to a social organization marked by the supremacy of a male figure, group of male figures, or men in general. It is depicted as subordinating women, children, and those whose genders or bodies defy traditional man/woman categorization.
 +
 +
In such a context, qualifying something as "patriarchical" implies a pejorative meaning. However, a man or woman can behave in a patriarchical manner. For instance, many activists during the [[Women's Health Movement]] criticized doctors for being patriarchical. While most doctors were male, many female doctors encountered the same accusations because they also engaged in behavior that subordinated women.
  
 
==Feminist view==
 
==Feminist view==
Line 64: Line 66:
  
 
According to French:
 
According to French:
:It is not enough either to devise a morality that will allow the human race simply to survive. Survival is an evil when it entails existing in a state of wretchedness. Intrinsic to survival and continuation is felicity, pleasure [...] But pleasure does not exclude serious pursuits or intentions, indeed, it is found in them, and it is the only real reason for staying alive" &mdash;[http://www.fragmentsweb.org/stuff/10french.html''Beyond Power: On Women, Men and Morals'']
+
:It is not enough either to devise a morality that will allow the human race simply to survive. Survival is an evil when it entails existing in a state of wretchedness. Intrinsic to survival and continuation is felicity, pleasure [...] But pleasure does not exclude serious pursuits or intentions, indeed, it is found in them, and it is the only real reason for staying alive"<ref>[http://www.fragmentsweb.org/stuff/10french.html''Beyond Power: On Women, Men and Morals'']</ref>
  
 
The latter philosophy is what French offers as a replacement to the current structure where, she says, power has the highest value.
 
The latter philosophy is what French offers as a replacement to the current structure where, she says, power has the highest value.
  
Gender-issues writer [[Cathy Young]], by contrast, dismisses reference to "patriarchy" as a semantic device intended to shield the speaker from accountability when making misandrist slurs, since "patriarchy" means all of Western society.[http://books.guardian.co.uk/review/story/0,,1327412,00.html] She cites Andrea Dworkin's criticism, "Under patriarchy, every woman's son is her potential betrayer and also the inevitable rapist or exploiter of another woman."
+
Gender-issues writer [[Cathy Young]], by contrast, dismisses reference to "patriarchy" as a semantic device intended to shield the speaker from accountability when making misandrist slurs, since "patriarchy" means all of Western society.<ref>[http://books.guardian.co.uk/review/story/0,,1327412,00.html]</ref> She cites Andrea Dworkin's criticism, "Under patriarchy, every woman's son is her potential betrayer and also the inevitable rapist or exploiter of another woman."
 +
 
 +
==References==
 +
<references/>
  
== References ==
+
==Bibliography==
 
* [[Pierre Bourdieu]], ''Masculine Domination'', Polity Press 2001
 
* [[Pierre Bourdieu]], ''Masculine Domination'', Polity Press 2001
 
* Robert Brown, ''Human Universals''. Philadelphia: Temple University Press 1991
 
* Robert Brown, ''Human Universals''. Philadelphia: Temple University Press 1991

Revision as of 09:13, 23 July 2006


Patriarchy (from Greek: patria meaning father and arché meaning rule) is the anthropological term used to define the sociological condition where male members of a society tend to predominate in positions of power; the more powerful the position, the more likely it is that a male will hold that position. The term "patriarchy" is also used in systems of ranking male leadership in certain hierarchical churches or religious bodies (see patriarch and Patriarchate). Examples include the Greek Orthodox and Russian Orthodox churches. "Patriarchy" is also used pejoratively to describe a seemingly immobile and sclerotic political order.

Definition

The term "patriarchy' is distinct from Patrilineality and Patrilocality. "Patrilineal" defines societies where the derivation of inheritence (financial or otherwise) originates from the father's line; a society with matrilineal traits such as Judaism, for example, provides that in order to be considered a Jew, a person must be born of a Jewish mother. "Patrilocal" defines a locus of control coming from the father's geographic/cultural community. In a matrilineal/matrilocal society, a woman will live with her mother and her sisters and brothers, even after marriage. She doesn't leave her maternal home. Her brothers act as 'social fathers' and will hold a higher influence on the women's offspring to the detriment of the children's biological father. Most societies are predominantly patrilineal and patrilocal, but this is not a universal (see: matriarchy).

Patrilineality

Patrilineality (a.k.a agnatic kinship) is a system in which one belongs to one's father's lineage; it generally involves the inheritance of property, names or titles through the male line as well.

A patriline is a line of descent from a male ancestor to a descendant (of either sex) in which the individuals in all intervening generations are male. In a patrilineal descent system (= agnatic descent), an individual is considered to belong to the same descent group as his or her father. This is in contrast to the less common pattern of matrilineal descent.

The agnatic ancestry of an individual is that person's pure male ancestry. An agnate is one's (male) relative in an unbroken male line: a kinsman with whom one has a common ancestor by descent in unbroken male line.

In medieval and later Europe, the Salic Law was purported to be the grounds for only males being able for hereditary succession to monarchies and fiefs, i.e in patrilieal or agnatic succession.

The fact that the Y chromosome is paternally inherited enables patrilines, and agnatic kinships, of men to be traced through genetic analysis.

The line of descent for monarchs and main personalities is almost exclusively through the main male personalities. See Davidic line.

Patrilocality

Patrilocality is a term used by social anthropologists to describe a socially instituted practice whereupon a married couple lives with or near the family of the husband.

A patrilocal residence is based on a rule that a man remains in his father's home after maturity. When he becomes married, his wife joins him in his father's home, where their children will be raised. These children will follow the same pattern: Sons will stay, and daughters will move in with their husbands' families. Household sizes grow greatly as this process continues.

Families living in a patrilocal residence generally assume joint ownership of domestic sources. The household is led by a senior member, who also directs the labor of all other members.

This practice is found in roughly 69% of the world's societies.

In anthropology

Human societies, whether they are ancient, indigenous or modern industrial, have been described in Anthropology in terms of either patriarchal or matriarchal systems. Between these polarities lie a number of social structures which include elements of both systems (see above under Patriarchy a discussion of the terms patrilinial and patrilocal ).

Anthropologist Donald Brown has listed patriarchy to be one of the "human universals" (Brown 1991, p. 137), which includes characteristics such as age gradation, personal hygiene, aesthetics, food sharing, rape, and other sociological aspects, implying that patriarchy is innate to the human condition. Margaret Mead has observed that "... all the claims so glibly made about societies ruled by women are nonsense. We have no reason to believe that they ever existed....Men have always been the leaders in public affairs and the final authorities at home."[1]

Societies have developed out of patriarchal cultures. Institutions of religion, education, commerce retain patriarchal practices. In Muslim counties today, patriarchy in the form of divided roles between of women and men into the domestic and social spheres is distinctly visible. In Europe and America whose cultures are based on a Christian model, political and religious power continues to exert a strong influence. The ideas of Age of Enlightenment philosophy, and Revolutionary movements including Feminism have brought about changes creating wider possibilities for both women and men. Marxist ideals support the advocacy of egalitarianism between the sexes, but these aspirations have been overtaken by authoritarian forms of political organisation in communist states. In China, for example, where by law the National People's Congress is composed of an equal number of men and women. There are, however, no women within the Politburo of the Communist Party of China, the agency that actually rules China. Prior to its dissolution, the Soviet Union's Congress of People's Deputies likewise consisted of equal numbers of men and women. Its successor, the Duma, which has governing authority, at present has only 35 woman deputies among the 450 members.[2]

This longstanding thesis has raised political opposition. The Modern Matriarchal Studies organization has held two conferences Luxembourg (2004) and San Marcos, Texas (2005) so as to redefine the term "matriarchy." www.hagia.de/ (hagia being derived from the Greek hagios or "holy"}. Various chairs, called "priestesses" in the group's literature, conducted workshops and at the end of the conference declared that “International Matriarchal Politics stands against white supremacist patriarchal capitalist homogenization and the globalization of misery. It stands for egalitarianism, diversity and the economics of the heart. Many matriarchal societies still exist around the world and they propose an alternative, life affirming model to patriarchal raptor capitalism."Societies of Peace Declaration (2005), 2-3

Chinese Patriarchy

Mencius outlined the Three Subordinations: A woman was to be subordinate to her father in youth, her husband in maturity, and her son in old age.

Repeated throughout ancient Chinese tradition, the familiar notion that men govern the outer world, while women govern the home serves as a cliche of classical texts.

In the Han dynasty, the female historian Ban Zhao wrote the Lessons for Women to advise women how to behave. She outlined the Four Virtues women must abide by: proper virtue, proper speech, proper countenance, and proper merit. The "three subordinations and the four virtues" became a common four-character phrase throughout the imperial period.

As for the historical development of Chinese patriarchy, women's status was highest in the Tang dynasty, when women played sports (polo) and were generally freer in fashion and conduct. Between the Tang and Song dynasties, a fad for little feet arose, and from the Song dynasty onwards footbinding became more and more common for the elite. In the Ming dynasty, a tradition of virtuous widowhood developed. Widows, even if widowed at a young age, were expected to not remarry. If they remained widows, their virtuous names might be displayed on the arch at the entrance of the village.

Symptoms of patriarchy in 20th and 21st century China include the immense pressure on women to get married before the age of 30 and the incidence of female infanticide associated with China's one child policy. However, footbinding has been eradicated and trafficking in women in China has greatly reduced.

In gender studies

In gender studies, the word patriarchy often refers to a social organization marked by the supremacy of a male figure, group of male figures, or men in general. It is depicted as subordinating women, children, and those whose genders or bodies defy traditional man/woman categorization.

In such a context, qualifying something as "patriarchical" implies a pejorative meaning. However, a man or woman can behave in a patriarchical manner. For instance, many activists during the Women's Health Movement criticized doctors for being patriarchical. While most doctors were male, many female doctors encountered the same accusations because they also engaged in behavior that subordinated women.

Feminist view

Many feminist writers have considered patriarchy to be the basis on which most modern societies have been formed. They argue that it is necessary and desirable to get away from this model in order to achieve gender equality.

Feminist writer Marilyn French, in her polemic Beyond Power, defines patriarchy as a system that values power over life, control over pleasure, and dominance over happiness. She argues that:

It is therefore extremely ironic that patriarchy has upheld power as a good that is permanent and dependable, opposing it to the fluid, transitory goods of matricentry. Power has been exalted as the bulwark against pain, against the ephemerality of pleasure, but it is no bulwark, and is as ephemeral as any other part of life...Yet so strong is the mythology of power that we continue to believe, in the face of all evidence to the contrary, that it is substantial, that if we possessed enough of it we could be happy, that if some "great man" possessed enough of it, he could make the world come right.

According to French:

It is not enough either to devise a morality that will allow the human race simply to survive. Survival is an evil when it entails existing in a state of wretchedness. Intrinsic to survival and continuation is felicity, pleasure [...] But pleasure does not exclude serious pursuits or intentions, indeed, it is found in them, and it is the only real reason for staying alive"[3]

The latter philosophy is what French offers as a replacement to the current structure where, she says, power has the highest value.

Gender-issues writer Cathy Young, by contrast, dismisses reference to "patriarchy" as a semantic device intended to shield the speaker from accountability when making misandrist slurs, since "patriarchy" means all of Western society.[4] She cites Andrea Dworkin's criticism, "Under patriarchy, every woman's son is her potential betrayer and also the inevitable rapist or exploiter of another woman."

References
ISBN links support NWE through referral fees

Bibliography

  • Pierre Bourdieu, Masculine Domination, Polity Press 2001
  • Robert Brown, Human Universals. Philadelphia: Temple University Press 1991
  • Margaret Mead, . (1950). Male and Female, Penguin, London.
  • Maria Mies, Patriarchy and Accumulation on a World Scale: Women in the International Division of Labour, Palgrave MacMillan 1999

External links


Credits

New World Encyclopedia writers and editors rewrote and completed the Wikipedia article in accordance with New World Encyclopedia standards. This article abides by terms of the Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 License (CC-by-sa), which may be used and disseminated with proper attribution. Credit is due under the terms of this license that can reference both the New World Encyclopedia contributors and the selfless volunteer contributors of the Wikimedia Foundation. To cite this article click here for a list of acceptable citing formats.The history of earlier contributions by wikipedians is accessible to researchers here:

The history of this article since it was imported to New World Encyclopedia:

Note: Some restrictions may apply to use of individual images which are separately licensed.