Difference between revisions of "Apollonius of Rhodes" - New World Encyclopedia

From New World Encyclopedia
 
(16 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ready}}{{Contracted}}{{claimed}}
+
{{ready}}{{Images OK}}{{submitted}}{{approved}}{{Paid}}{{copyedited}}
  
'''Apollonius of [[Rhodes]]''', also known as '''Apollonius Rhodius''' (early [[third century B.C.E.]] - after 246 B.C.E.), was an [[Epic poetry|epic poet]], [[scholar]], and director of the [[Library of Alexandria|Library]] of [[Alexandria]]. He is best known for his epic poem the ''[[Argonautica]]'', which told of the mythological story of [[Jason]] and the [[Argonauts]]' quest for the [[Golden Fleece]] and is one of the chief works in the history of epic poetry.
+
[[Image:Jason-Fleece.jpg|thumb|200px|Jason and the Golden Fleece, from Apollonius' ''[[Argonautica]]'']]
  
Apollonius did not come from Rhodes; he only lived in Rhodes for part of his life and while living there, adopted "Rhodian" as a surname.
+
'''Apollonius of [[Rhodes]],''' also known as '''Apollonius Rhodius''' (early [[third century B.C.E.]] - after 246 B.C.E.), was an [[Epic poetry|epic poet]], [[scholar]], and director of the [[Library of Alexandria]]. He is best known for his epic poem, the ''[[Argonautica]],'' which told of the mythological story of [[Jason]] and the [[Argonauts]]' quest for the [[Golden Fleece]] and is one of the chief works in the history of epic poetry.  
  
Like [[Homer]]'s ''[[Iliad]]'' and ''[[Odyssey]]'', ''Argonautica'' is written in [[hexameter]]s and is comparable to these [[epic poems]]. Often, Apollonius paraphrases the old master, who was very popular at the court of the Ptolemaic rulers [[Ptolemy IV Philopator]] and [[Arsinoe III]]. There is a big difference with Homer, however: Callimachus' heroes and heroines are, from a psychological point of view, more complex and credible. Apollonius's poem inspired the Roman [[Valerius Flaccus]]' ''Argonautica''.
+
Like [[Homer]]'s ''[[Iliad]]'' and ''[[Odyssey]],'' ''Argonautica'' was written in [[hexameter]]s and is comparable to these [[epic poems]]. Often, Apollonius paraphrases Homer, who was very popular at the court of the Ptolemaic rulers, [[Ptolemy IV Philopator]] and [[Arsinoe III]]. There is a major difference between Apollonius' heroes and those of Homer, however: Apollonius' heroes and heroines are, from a psychological point of view, more complex and credible. Apollonius's poem inspired the Roman [[Valerius Flaccus]]' ''Argonautica''.
 +
{{toc}}
 +
The sources dealing with Apollonius's life are sketchy and often contradictory. It is clear, however, Apollonius was not born in Rhodes, but adopted the surname "Rhodius" while living there. He was born in either Alexandria or Naucratis, which lay south of Alexandria on the [[Nile]]. He lived for a time in Rhodes, and he held the post of Librarian at least until 246 B.C.E. He was a student of the poet and scholar [[Callimachus]], and there are also accounts of a later, bitter feud between the student and his mentor.
  
 
==Life==
 
==Life==
===Sources===
+
There are four main sources of information on Apollonius' life: Two texts entitled, ''Life of Apollonius;'' an entry on him in the [[tenth century]] encyclopedia, the ''[[Suda]];'' and a [[second century B.C.E.]] [[papyrus]], [[Oxyrhynchus|P.Oxy.]] 1241, which provides the names of several heads of the [[Library of Alexandria]]. Other miscellaneous texts provide further information.
There are four main sources of information on Apollonius' life: two texts entitled ''Life of Apollonius'' found in the [[scholia]] on Apollonius; the entry on him in the [[tenth-century]] encyclopaedia the ''[[Suda]]''; and a [[second-century B.C.E.]] [[papyrus]], [[Oxyrhynchus|P.Oxy.]] 1241, which provides names of several heads of the [[Library of Alexandria]]. Of these P.Oxy. 1241 carries much more weight than the others, as it is by far the closest to Apollonius' lifetime. Other miscellaneous texts provide further information.
 
 
   
 
   
===Well-established events===
+
'''Birth:''' The two ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' name Apollonius' father as Silleus or Illeus. The second ''Life'' names his mother as "Rhode," meaning "Rhodian woman," but this may merely be an attempt to explain Apollonius' epithet "Rhodian." The ''Lives,'' the ''Suda,'' and the historian [[Strabo]] all agree that Apollonius came from Alexandria; [[Athenaeus]] and [[Aelian]], however, say that he came from [[Naucratis]], some 43.5 miles south of [[Alexandria]] along the river [[Nile]].<ref>Athenaeus, [http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Athenaeus/1A*.html ''Deipnosophistae'' 7.19.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref> No source gives the date of his birth.
''Birth:'' The two ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' name Apollonius' father as Silleus or Illeus. (The second ''Life'' names his mother as "Rhode," but this is unlikely; ''Rhodē'' means "Rhodian woman," and is almost certainly derived from an attempt to explain Apollonius' epithet "Rhodian".) The ''Lives'', the ''Suda'', and the geographical writer [[Strabo]] say that he came from Alexandria;<ref>Strabo 14.2.13.</ref> [[Athenaeus]] and [[Aelian]] say that he came from [[Naucratis]], some 43.5 miles south of [[Alexandria]] along the river [[Nile]].<ref>Athenaeus ''Deipnosophistae'' 7.19 [http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Athenaeus/1A*.html full text] Retrieved October 5, 2007.; Aelian ''On the nature of animals'' 15.23.</ref> No source gives the date of his birth.
 
  
''Student of Callimachus:'' The ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' agree that Apollonius was a student of the poet and scholar [[Callimachus]]. The second ''Life'' adds that "some say" Apollonius was buried with Callimachus.
+
[[Image:Ancientlibraryalex.jpg|thumb|250px|The Great Library of Alexandria, of which Apollonius was the director]]
  
''Head of the Library of Alexandria:'' The second ''Life'', the ''Suda'', and P.Oxy. 1241 attest that Apollonius held this post. P.Oxy. 1241 establishes moreover that Apollonius was succeeded by [[Eratosthenes]]; this must have been after 247/246 B.C.E., the date of the accession of [[Ptolemy III Euergetes]], who seems to be the monarch that appointed Eratosthenes. (The ''Suda'' says that Apollonius succeeded Eratosthenes, but this is impossible: Apollonius studied with Callimachus, who died ca. 240 B.C.E.; the first ''Life'' says Apollonius was contemporary with Ptolemy III; and Eratosthenes held the post until at least 204 B.C.E.)<ref>The ''Suda'' entry on Eratosthenes says that Eratosthenes held the post from the reign of [[Ptolemy III Euergetes]] until [[Ptolemy V]], ''Suda'' 2898 s.v. {{polytonic|Ἐρατοσθένης}}.</ref>
+
'''Student of Callimachus:''' The ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' agree that Apollonius was a student of the poet and scholar [[Callimachus]]. The second ''Life'' adds that "some say" Apollonius was buried with Callimachus.
  
''Removal from Alexandria to Rhodes:'' The ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' attest to this; so does the attachment of the epithet ''Rhodios'' "the Rhodian" to his name. What is uncertain is whether he died there, or came back to Alexandria in order to take up the position of head of the Library afterwards.
+
'''Head of the Library of Alexandria:''' The second ''Life,'' the ''Suda<'' and P.Oxy. 1241 attest that Apollonius held this post. P. Oxy. 1241 establishes that Apollonius was succeeded by [[Eratosthenes]]; this must have been after 247/246 B.C.E., the date of the accession of [[Ptolemy III Euergetes]], who seems to be the monarch that appointed Eratosthenes.
  
''Death:'' Only the two ''Lives'' give information about Apollonius' death, and they disagree. The first says he died in Rhodes; the second says he died after returning to Alexandria.
+
The ''Suda'' says that Apollonius succeeded Eratosthenes, but this is impossible: Apollonius studied with Callimachus, who died ca. 240 B.C.E.; the first ''Life'' says Apollonius was contemporary with Ptolemy III; and Eratosthenes held the post until at least 204 B.C.E.. The ''Suda'' entry on Eratosthenes says that Eratosthenes held the post from the reign of [[Ptolemy III Euergetes]] until [[Ptolemy V]].
  
From this we can conclude that (1) Apollonius was born in either Alexandria or Naucratis; (2) he lived for a time in Rhodes; (3) he held the post of Librarian at least until 246 B.C.E. From this in turn we may infer that he lived in the early-to-mid [[third century B.C.E.]]. Beyond this point lies speculation.
+
'''Move from Alexandria to Rhodes:''' The ''Lives'' and the ''Suda'' attest to Apollonius moving from Alexandria to Rhodes. It is uncertain, however, whether he died there, or whether he came back to Alexandria in order to take up the position of head of the Library after his time in Rhodes.
  
==Sensational stories==
+
'''Death:''' Only the two ''Lives'' give information about Apollonius' death, and they disagree. The first says he died in Rhodes; the second says he died after returning to Alexandria.
The [[Greek Anthology|Palatine Anthology]] preserves an epigram, attributed to "Apollonius the grammarian," which mocks Callimachus and his most famous poem, the ''Aetia'' ("''Causes''"):<ref>''Pal. Anth''. 11.322. The translation given here is modelled on that of H.J. Rose.</ref>
 
  
<blockquote> {{polytonic|Καλλίμαχος, τὸ κάθαρμα, τὸ παίγνιον, ὁ ξυλινὸς νοῦς, <br /> &nbsp;&nbsp; αἴτιος, ὁ γράψας Αἴτια Καλλιμάχου.}} </blockquote>
+
From this, one can conclude that (1) Apollonius was born in either Alexandria or Naucratis; (2) he lived for a time in Rhodes; (3) he held the post of Librarian at least until 246 B.C.E.. From this, in turn, one may infer that he lived in the early-to-mid [[third century B.C.E.]] Beyond this point lies only speculation.
<blockquote> Callimachus: trash, cheat, wood-for-brains. <br /> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; ''aitios'' ("guilty"): the one who wrote Callimachus' ''Aitia'' ("''Causes''"). </blockquote>
 
  
In addition, multiple sources explain Callimachus' poem ''Ibis'' &mdash; which does not survive &mdash; as a polemic against an enemy identified as Apollonius.<ref>E.g. the ''Suda'' entry on Callimachus, ''Suda'' 227, s.v. {{polytonic|Καλλίμαχος}}.</ref> Between them, these references conjure up images of a sensational literary feud between the two figures. However, the truth of this story continues to be debated in modern scholarship, with views on both sides. Both of the ''Lives'' of Apollonius stress the friendship between the poets; the second ''Life'' even saying they were buried together; and some scholars doubt the sources that identify the ''Ibis'' as a polemic against Apollonius. There is still not a consensus, but most scholars of Hellenistic literature now believe the feud was enormously sensationalized, if it happened at all.<ref>Thus D.P. Nelis 1999, review of P. Green 1997, ''Apollonius: the Argonautica'' (Berkeley), in ''Journal of Hellenic Studies'' 119: 187. For a recent summary of contrasting views, see e.g. A. Cameron 1995, ''Callimachus and his Critics'' Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press, 1995. ISBN 0691043671 ISBN 9780691043678</ref>
+
==Sensational stories==
 +
A number of sources speak of a bitter feud between Apollonius and his former teacher, [[Callimachus]]. The [[Greek Anthology|Palatine Anthology]] preserves an epigram, attributed to "Apollonius the grammarian," which mocks Callimachus and his most famous poem, the ''Aetia'' ''(Causes)'': "Callimachus: Trash, cheat, wood-for-brains."<ref>''Pal. Anth''. 11.322.</ref> In addition, multiple sources explain Callimachus' poem, ''Ibis''&mdash; which has not survived&mdash;as a polemic against an enemy identified as Apollonius. Between them, these references conjure up images of a sensational literary feud between the two figures. However, the truth of this story continues to be debated in modern scholarship, with views on both sides. Both of the ''Lives'' of Apollonius stress the friendship between the poets; the second ''Life'' even claims they were buried together; and some scholars doubt the sources that identify the ''Ibis'' as a polemic against Apollonius. There is still not a consensus, but most scholars of Hellenistic literature now believe the feud was enormously sensationalized, if it happened at all.<ref>D.P. Nelis 1999, review of P. Green 1997, ''Apollonius: the Argonautica'' (Berkeley), in ''Journal of Hellenic Studies'' 119: 187.</ref>
  
A second sensationalized story about Apollonius is the account in the ''Lives'' of how, as a young man, he gave a performance of his epic the ''Argonautica'' in Alexandria. He was universally mocked for it, and fled to Rhodes in shame. There he was feted by the Rhodians and given citizenship. After this, according to the second ''Life'', he made a triumphant return to Alexandria, where he was promptly elevated to head of the Library. It is unlikely that much of this is factual; the story is a mixture of "local boy makes good" and "underdog makes a heroic comeback." Fairytale elements such as these are characteristic of ancient biographies.
+
A second sensationalized story about Apollonius is the account in the ''Lives'' of how, as a young man, he gave a performance of his epic, the ''Argonautica,'' in Alexandria. He was universally mocked for it, and fled to Rhodes in shame. There, he was feted by the Rhodians and given citizenship. After this, according to the second ''Life,'' he made a triumphant return to Alexandria, where he was promptly elevated to head of the Library. It is unlikely that much of this is factual; the story is a mixture of "local boy makes good" and "underdog makes a heroic comeback." Fairytale elements such as these are characteristic of ancient biographies.
  
 
==The ''Argonautica''==
 
==The ''Argonautica''==
The ''Argonautica'' differs in some respects from traditional or Homeric Greek epic, though Apollonius certainly used Homer as a model. The ''Argonautica'' is shorter than Homer’s epics, with four books totaling less than 6,000 lines, while the [[Iliad]] runs to more than 16,000. Apollonius may have been influenced here by Callimachus’ brevity, or by [[Aristotle]]’s demand for "poems on a smaller scale than the old epics, and answering in length to the group of tragedies presented at a single sitting" (the ''Poetics'').
+
[[Image:Building Argo BM TerrD603.jpg|thumb|250px|Athena (left) helps build the ship ''[[Argo]]''; Roman molded terracotta plaque, first century C.E.]]
 +
The ''Argonautica'' differs in some respects from traditional or Homeric Greek epic, though Apollonius certainly used Homer as a model.  
  
Apollonius' epic also differs from the more traditional epic in its weaker, more human protagonist Jason, and in its many discursions into local custom ([[aetiology]]), and other popular subjects of Hellenistic poetry. Apollonius also chooses the less-shocking versions of some myths, having [[Medea]], for example, merely watch the murder of [[Apsyrtus]] instead of murdering him, herself. The gods are relatively distant and inactive throughout much of the epic, following the Hellenistic trend to allegorize and rationalize religion. Heterosexual loves such as Jason's are emphasized more than [[homosexuality|homosexual]] loves, such as that of [[Heracles]] and [[Hylas]], another trend in Hellenistic literature. Many critics regard the love of Medea and Jason in the third book as the best written and most memorable episode.
+
For one thing, the ''Argonautica'' is shorter than Homer’s epics, with four books totaling less than 6,000 lines, while the ''[[Iliad]]'' runs to more than 16,000 lines. Apollonius may have been influenced here by Callimachus’ brevity, or by [[Aristotle]]’s recommendation that poems be "on a smaller scale than the old epics, and answering in length to the group of tragedies presented at a single sitting" (the ''Poetics'').
 +
 
 +
Apollonius' epic also differs from the more traditional epic in its very human protagonist, Jason. Both this hero and others appear more three-dimensional and psychologically credible in Apollonius' work. ''Argonautica'' also gives many accounts of the origins of local customs ([[aetiology]]) and other popular subjects of Hellenistic poetry. Apollonius also chooses the less-shocking versions of some [[myth]]s, having [[Medea]], for example, merely watch the murder of [[Apsyrtus]] instead of murdering him herself. The gods are relatively distant and inactive throughout much of the epic, following the Hellenistic trend to allegorize and rationalize religion. Heterosexual loves such as Jason's are emphasized more than [[homosexuality|homosexual]] loves, such as that of [[Heracles]] and [[Hylas]], another trend in Hellenistic literature. Many critics regard the love of Medea and Jason in the third book as the best written and most memorable episode.
  
 
==Legacy==
 
==Legacy==
Opinions on Apollonius' lasting contribution to Western literature, the ''Argonautica'', have changed over time. Some critics in antiquity considered it mediocre.<ref>Pseudo-[[Longinus]] ''On the sublime'' 33.4 [http://evans-experientialism.freewebspace.com/longinus07.htm full text]; [[Quintilian]] ''Institutio oratoria'' 10.54 [http://rhetoric.byu.edu/Primary%20Texts/Quintilian.htm compact outline]. Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref> Recent criticism has seen a renaissance of interest in the poem and an awareness of its qualities, with numerous scholarly studies published regularly. Its influence on later poets like [[Virgil]] is now well recognized, and any account of the history of epic poetry now routinely includes substantial attention to Apollonius.
+
Opinions on Apollonius' lasting contribution to Western literature, the ''Argonautica,'' have changed over time. Some critics in antiquity considered it mediocre.<ref>Pseudo-[[Longinus]], [http://evans-experientialism.freewebspace.com/longinus07.htm On the Sublime.] Retrieved December 20, 2007.</ref> Recent criticism has seen a renaissance of interest in the poem and an awareness of its qualities, with numerous scholarly studies published regularly. Its influence on later poets, like [[Virgil]], is now well recognized, and any account of the history of epic poetry now routinely includes substantial attention to Apollonius.
  
 
== Notes ==
 
== Notes ==
<div class="references-small">
+
 
 
<references />
 
<references />
</div>
 
  
 
== References ==
 
== References ==
*Hunter, Richard L. ''Jason and the Golden Fleece'', Oxford University Press, 1998. ISBN 0-19-283583-1
+
* Beye, Charles Rowan. ''Ancient Epic Poetry: Homer, Apollonius, Virgil, with a Chapter on the Gilgamesh Poems.'' Bolchazy Carducci Pub., 2006. ISBN 0-86516-607-2
*Beye, Charles Rowan. ''Ancient Epic Poetry: Homer, Apollonius, Virgil'', Ithaca, 1993. ISBN 0-86516-607-2
+
* Cameron, Alan. ''Callimachus and his Critics''. Princeton University Press, 1995. ISBN 9780691043678
* Clare, R.J. ''The Path of the Argo: Language, Imagery and Narrative in the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius'', Cambridge University Press, 2002. ISBN 0-521-81036-1
+
* Clare, R.J. ''The Path of the Argo: Language, Imagery and Narrative in the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius''. Cambridge University Press, 2002. ISBN 0-521-81036-1
* Harder, M.A., & M. Cuypers (edd.) ''Beginning from Apollo: Studies in Apollonius Rhodius and the Argonautic Tradition'', Leuven, 2005. ISBN 90-429-1629-X
+
* Harder, M.A. & M. Cuypers (ed.) ''Beginning from Apollo: Studies in Apollonius Rhodius and the Argonautic Tradition''. Peeters, 2006. ISBN 90-429-1629-X
*Hunter, Richard L. ''The Argonautica of Apollonius: Literary Studies'', Cambridge University Press, 1993. ISBN 0-521-41372-9
+
* Hunter, Richard L. ''The Argonautica of Apollonius: Literary Studies''. Cambridge University Press, 1993. ISBN 0-521-41372-9
* Nelis, D.P. ''Vergil's Aeneid and the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius'', Leeds University Press, 2001. ISBN 0-905205-97-9
+
* Nelis, D.P. ''Vergil's Aeneid and the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius''. Leeds University Press, 2001. ISBN 0-905205-97-9
 +
* Rhodes, Apollonius. ''Jason and the Golden Fleece''. Francis Cairns Publications, 1998. ISBN 0-19-283583-1
  
 
== External links ==
 
== External links ==
* {{gutenberg author| id=Rhodius+Apollonius | name=Apollonius of Rhodes}}Retrieved October 5, 2007.
+
All links retrieved August 11, 2023.
 +
 
 +
* {{gutenberg author| id=Rhodius+Apollonius | name=Apollonius of Rhodes}} ''www.gutenberg.org''.  
  
  

Latest revision as of 15:46, 11 August 2023


Jason and the Golden Fleece, from Apollonius' Argonautica

Apollonius of Rhodes, also known as Apollonius Rhodius (early third century B.C.E. - after 246 B.C.E.), was an epic poet, scholar, and director of the Library of Alexandria. He is best known for his epic poem, the Argonautica, which told of the mythological story of Jason and the Argonauts' quest for the Golden Fleece and is one of the chief works in the history of epic poetry.

Like Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, Argonautica was written in hexameters and is comparable to these epic poems. Often, Apollonius paraphrases Homer, who was very popular at the court of the Ptolemaic rulers, Ptolemy IV Philopator and Arsinoe III. There is a major difference between Apollonius' heroes and those of Homer, however: Apollonius' heroes and heroines are, from a psychological point of view, more complex and credible. Apollonius's poem inspired the Roman Valerius Flaccus' Argonautica.

The sources dealing with Apollonius's life are sketchy and often contradictory. It is clear, however, Apollonius was not born in Rhodes, but adopted the surname "Rhodius" while living there. He was born in either Alexandria or Naucratis, which lay south of Alexandria on the Nile. He lived for a time in Rhodes, and he held the post of Librarian at least until 246 B.C.E. He was a student of the poet and scholar Callimachus, and there are also accounts of a later, bitter feud between the student and his mentor.

Life

There are four main sources of information on Apollonius' life: Two texts entitled, Life of Apollonius; an entry on him in the tenth century encyclopedia, the Suda; and a second century B.C.E. papyrus, P.Oxy. 1241, which provides the names of several heads of the Library of Alexandria. Other miscellaneous texts provide further information.

Birth: The two Lives and the Suda name Apollonius' father as Silleus or Illeus. The second Life names his mother as "Rhode," meaning "Rhodian woman," but this may merely be an attempt to explain Apollonius' epithet "Rhodian." The Lives, the Suda, and the historian Strabo all agree that Apollonius came from Alexandria; Athenaeus and Aelian, however, say that he came from Naucratis, some 43.5 miles south of Alexandria along the river Nile.[1] No source gives the date of his birth.

The Great Library of Alexandria, of which Apollonius was the director

Student of Callimachus: The Lives and the Suda agree that Apollonius was a student of the poet and scholar Callimachus. The second Life adds that "some say" Apollonius was buried with Callimachus.

Head of the Library of Alexandria: The second Life, the Suda< and P.Oxy. 1241 attest that Apollonius held this post. P. Oxy. 1241 establishes that Apollonius was succeeded by Eratosthenes; this must have been after 247/246 B.C.E., the date of the accession of Ptolemy III Euergetes, who seems to be the monarch that appointed Eratosthenes.

The Suda says that Apollonius succeeded Eratosthenes, but this is impossible: Apollonius studied with Callimachus, who died ca. 240 B.C.E.; the first Life says Apollonius was contemporary with Ptolemy III; and Eratosthenes held the post until at least 204 B.C.E. The Suda entry on Eratosthenes says that Eratosthenes held the post from the reign of Ptolemy III Euergetes until Ptolemy V.

Move from Alexandria to Rhodes: The Lives and the Suda attest to Apollonius moving from Alexandria to Rhodes. It is uncertain, however, whether he died there, or whether he came back to Alexandria in order to take up the position of head of the Library after his time in Rhodes.

Death: Only the two Lives give information about Apollonius' death, and they disagree. The first says he died in Rhodes; the second says he died after returning to Alexandria.

From this, one can conclude that (1) Apollonius was born in either Alexandria or Naucratis; (2) he lived for a time in Rhodes; (3) he held the post of Librarian at least until 246 B.C.E. From this, in turn, one may infer that he lived in the early-to-mid third century B.C.E. Beyond this point lies only speculation.

Sensational stories

A number of sources speak of a bitter feud between Apollonius and his former teacher, Callimachus. The Palatine Anthology preserves an epigram, attributed to "Apollonius the grammarian," which mocks Callimachus and his most famous poem, the Aetia (Causes): "Callimachus: Trash, cheat, wood-for-brains."[2] In addition, multiple sources explain Callimachus' poem, Ibis— which has not survived—as a polemic against an enemy identified as Apollonius. Between them, these references conjure up images of a sensational literary feud between the two figures. However, the truth of this story continues to be debated in modern scholarship, with views on both sides. Both of the Lives of Apollonius stress the friendship between the poets; the second Life even claims they were buried together; and some scholars doubt the sources that identify the Ibis as a polemic against Apollonius. There is still not a consensus, but most scholars of Hellenistic literature now believe the feud was enormously sensationalized, if it happened at all.[3]

A second sensationalized story about Apollonius is the account in the Lives of how, as a young man, he gave a performance of his epic, the Argonautica, in Alexandria. He was universally mocked for it, and fled to Rhodes in shame. There, he was feted by the Rhodians and given citizenship. After this, according to the second Life, he made a triumphant return to Alexandria, where he was promptly elevated to head of the Library. It is unlikely that much of this is factual; the story is a mixture of "local boy makes good" and "underdog makes a heroic comeback." Fairytale elements such as these are characteristic of ancient biographies.

The Argonautica

Athena (left) helps build the ship Argo; Roman molded terracotta plaque, first century C.E.

The Argonautica differs in some respects from traditional or Homeric Greek epic, though Apollonius certainly used Homer as a model.

For one thing, the Argonautica is shorter than Homer’s epics, with four books totaling less than 6,000 lines, while the Iliad runs to more than 16,000 lines. Apollonius may have been influenced here by Callimachus’ brevity, or by Aristotle’s recommendation that poems be "on a smaller scale than the old epics, and answering in length to the group of tragedies presented at a single sitting" (the Poetics).

Apollonius' epic also differs from the more traditional epic in its very human protagonist, Jason. Both this hero and others appear more three-dimensional and psychologically credible in Apollonius' work. Argonautica also gives many accounts of the origins of local customs (aetiology) and other popular subjects of Hellenistic poetry. Apollonius also chooses the less-shocking versions of some myths, having Medea, for example, merely watch the murder of Apsyrtus instead of murdering him herself. The gods are relatively distant and inactive throughout much of the epic, following the Hellenistic trend to allegorize and rationalize religion. Heterosexual loves such as Jason's are emphasized more than homosexual loves, such as that of Heracles and Hylas, another trend in Hellenistic literature. Many critics regard the love of Medea and Jason in the third book as the best written and most memorable episode.

Legacy

Opinions on Apollonius' lasting contribution to Western literature, the Argonautica, have changed over time. Some critics in antiquity considered it mediocre.[4] Recent criticism has seen a renaissance of interest in the poem and an awareness of its qualities, with numerous scholarly studies published regularly. Its influence on later poets, like Virgil, is now well recognized, and any account of the history of epic poetry now routinely includes substantial attention to Apollonius.

Notes

  1. Athenaeus, Deipnosophistae 7.19. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  2. Pal. Anth. 11.322.
  3. D.P. Nelis 1999, review of P. Green 1997, Apollonius: the Argonautica (Berkeley), in Journal of Hellenic Studies 119: 187.
  4. Pseudo-Longinus, On the Sublime. Retrieved December 20, 2007.

References
ISBN links support NWE through referral fees

  • Beye, Charles Rowan. Ancient Epic Poetry: Homer, Apollonius, Virgil, with a Chapter on the Gilgamesh Poems. Bolchazy Carducci Pub., 2006. ISBN 0-86516-607-2
  • Cameron, Alan. Callimachus and his Critics. Princeton University Press, 1995. ISBN 9780691043678
  • Clare, R.J. The Path of the Argo: Language, Imagery and Narrative in the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius. Cambridge University Press, 2002. ISBN 0-521-81036-1
  • Harder, M.A. & M. Cuypers (ed.) Beginning from Apollo: Studies in Apollonius Rhodius and the Argonautic Tradition. Peeters, 2006. ISBN 90-429-1629-X
  • Hunter, Richard L. The Argonautica of Apollonius: Literary Studies. Cambridge University Press, 1993. ISBN 0-521-41372-9
  • Nelis, D.P. Vergil's Aeneid and the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius. Leeds University Press, 2001. ISBN 0-905205-97-9
  • Rhodes, Apollonius. Jason and the Golden Fleece. Francis Cairns Publications, 1998. ISBN 0-19-283583-1

External links

All links retrieved August 11, 2023.

Credits

New World Encyclopedia writers and editors rewrote and completed the Wikipedia article in accordance with New World Encyclopedia standards. This article abides by terms of the Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 License (CC-by-sa), which may be used and disseminated with proper attribution. Credit is due under the terms of this license that can reference both the New World Encyclopedia contributors and the selfless volunteer contributors of the Wikimedia Foundation. To cite this article click here for a list of acceptable citing formats.The history of earlier contributions by wikipedians is accessible to researchers here:

The history of this article since it was imported to New World Encyclopedia:

Note: Some restrictions may apply to use of individual images which are separately licensed.