Difference between revisions of "Masada" - New World Encyclopedia

From New World Encyclopedia
m (Rename History and biography to History)
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Claimed}}{{Contracted}}{{Submitted}}
+
{{Ebapproved}}{{approved}}{{Images OK}}{{Submitted}}{{Paid}}{{copyedited}}
  
 
{{Infobox Military Conflict
 
{{Infobox Military Conflict
Line 6: Line 6:
 
|image=[[Image:Massada_Israel.jpg|300px]]
 
|image=[[Image:Massada_Israel.jpg|300px]]
 
|caption=Masada seen from the east
 
|caption=Masada seen from the east
|date=Late 72 – early 73 C.E.
+
|date=Late 72 C.E.–early 73 C.E.
 
|place=Masada, in modern-day eastern [[Israel]]
 
|place=Masada, in modern-day eastern [[Israel]]
 
|territory=
 
|territory=
Line 19: Line 19:
 
|casualties2=Unknown, if any
 
|casualties2=Unknown, if any
 
}}
 
}}
'''Masada''' (a [[romanization]] of the [[Hebrew language|Hebrew]] מצדה, ''Mitzada'', from מצודה, ''metzuda'', "fortress") is the name for a site of ancient [[palace]]s and [[fortification]]s in the [[South District (Israel)|South District]] of [[Israel]] on top of an isolated rock [[plateau]] on the eastern edge of the [[Judean Desert]] overlooking the [[Dead Sea]]. Masada became famous for its significance in the [[First Jewish-Roman War]] (Great Jewish Revolt), when a [[siege]] of the fortress by troops of the [[Roman Empire]] allegedly led to a [[mass suicide]] of the site's Jewish Sicarii or Zealot defenders when defeat became imminent. While the fate of the rebels is disputed, Masada came to symbolyze for Jews courage, patriotism and self-defense. Its story has helped to counter the sentiment that Jews were always victims, always subject to other peoples' action, never actors in their own right. In this view, whether by their own hand or at the hands of others, the defenders of Masada resisted, and died bravely. Modern Israeli soldiers have vowed to defend the State of Israel standing atop the fortress. Before the Fall of Masada, though, Zealots did not hesitate to kill fellow Jews, women and children included, on their forages for food into the countryside, since they considered such people wicked and damned anyone (they were not among the elect, unlike the Zealots).<ref>See  Ben-Yehuda, Nachman "The Masada Myth: Scholars present evidence that the heroes of the Jewish Great Revolt were not heroes at all", Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Hebrew University, Jerusalem  [http://www.bibleinterp.com/articles/masadamyth1.htm The Masada Myth] Retrieved September 7, 2007</ref>. An element of revisionism is present in how the Masada-Zealots have been recruited to support more morally worthy causes, such as the [[Warsaw Uprising]] during [[World War II]], which the Masada story helped to inspire.  What has been called the Masada-myth helped to "To counteract the poisonous European anti-Semitic image of the Jew as non-heroic " <ref>ibid</ref>.
+
'''Masada''' (a [[romanization]] of the [[Hebrew language|Hebrew]] מצדה, ''Mitzada,'' from מצודה, ''metzuda,'' "fortress") is the name for a site of ancient [[palace]]s and [[fortification]]s in the [[South District (Israel)|South District]] of [[Israel]] on top of an isolated rock [[plateau]] on the eastern edge of the [[Judean Desert]] overlooking the [[Dead Sea]]. Masada became famous for its significance in the [[First Jewish-Roman War]] (Great Jewish Revolt), when a [[siege]] of the fortress by troops of the [[Roman Empire]] allegedly led to a [[mass suicide]] of the site's Jewish Sicarii or Zealot defenders when defeat became imminent.  
 
+
{{toc}}
 +
Masada came to symbolize courage, patriotism, and self-defense for Jews. Its story has helped to counter the sentiment that Jews were always victims, always subject to other peoples' action, and never actors in their own right. In this view, the defenders of Masada resisted and died bravely, whether by their own hand or at the hands of others. Modern Israeli soldiers have often made vows to defend the State of Israel standing atop the fortress. The Masada story also helped to inspire the [[Warsaw Uprising]] during [[World War II]], one of the first modern instances when Jews put aside their traditional submissive posture to take up heroic though futile resistance against an overwhelming oppressor.
  
 
==Geography==
 
==Geography==
The cliffs on the east edge of Masada are about 1300 feet high, dropping off to the [[Dead Sea]], and the cliffs on the west are about 300 feet high; the natural approaches to the cliff top are very difficult. The top of the plateau is flat and [[rhomboid]]-shaped, about 1800 by 900 feet. The center of the plateau is at {{coor dms|31|18|55|N|35|21|13|E|}}. There was a casemate wall around the top of the plateau totaling 4300 feet long and 12 foot thick with many towers, and the fortress included storehouses, [[barrack]]s, an [[armory]], the palace, and [[cistern]]s that were refilled by [[rainwater]]. Three narrow, winding paths led from below to fortified gates.  
+
The cliffs on the east edge of Masada are about 1,300 feet high, dropping off to the [[Dead Sea]], and the cliffs on the west are about three hundred feet high; the natural approaches to the cliff top are very difficult. The top of the plateau is flat and [[rhomboid]]-shaped, about 1,800 by 900 feet. There was a casemate wall around the top of the plateau totaling 4,300 feet long and 12 feet thick with many towers, and the fortress included storehouses, [[barrack]]s, an [[armory]], the palace, and [[cistern]]s that were refilled by [[rainwater]]. Three narrow, winding paths led from below to fortified gates.  
  
 
==History==
 
==History==
 
[[Image:Masada01.jpg|left|thumb|left|160px|[[Dovecote]] at Masada, where ashes were probably stored—the openings have been shown to be too small for pigeons to fit.]]
 
[[Image:Masada01.jpg|left|thumb|left|160px|[[Dovecote]] at Masada, where ashes were probably stored—the openings have been shown to be too small for pigeons to fit.]]
  
According to [[Josephus|Flavius Josephus]], a [[First century|first-century]] [[Jew]]ish [[Ancient Rome|Roman]] historian, [[Herod the Great]] fortified Masada between 37 and 31 B.C.E. as a refuge for himself in the event of a revolt. In 66 C.E., at the beginning of the First Jewish-Roman War (also called the Great Jewish Revolt) against the Roman Empire, a group of Jewish rebels called the [[Zealotry|Zealots]] (''kana'im'', "zealous ones," commanded by Elazar ben Ya'ir (who may have been the same person as [[Eleazar ben Simon]]), who objected to Roman rule of [[Judea]] (as the [[Roman province]] of [[Iudaea Province|Iudaea]], its [[Latin language|Latin]] name) took Masada from the Roman [[garrison]] stationed there. In 70, they were joined by additional Zealots and their families who were expelled from [[Jerusalem]] by the other Jews living there shortly before the [[destruction of Jerusalem]] (and the [[Second Temple]]), and for the next two years used Masada as their base for raiding and harassing Roman and Jewish settlements alike.
+
According to [[Josephus|Flavius Josephus]], a [[First century|first century]] [[Jew]]ish [[Ancient Rome|Roman]] historian, [[Herod the Great]] fortified Masada between 37 and 31 B.C.E. as a refuge for himself in the event of a revolt. In 66 C.E., at the beginning of the First Jewish-Roman War (also called the Great Jewish Revolt) against the Roman Empire, a group of Jewish rebels called the [[Zealotry|Zealots]] (''kana'im,'' "zealous ones," commanded by Elazar ben Ya'ir (who may have been the same person as [[Eleazar ben Simon]]), who objected to Roman rule of [[Judea]] (as the [[Roman province]] of [[Iudaea Province|Iudaea]], its [[Latin language|Latin]] name) took Masada from the Roman [[garrison]] stationed there. In 70 C.E., they were joined by additional Zealots and their families who were expelled from [[Jerusalem]] by the other Jews living there shortly before the [[destruction of Jerusalem]] (and the [[Second Temple]]), and for the next two years used Masada as their base for raiding and harassing Roman and Jewish settlements alike.
  
 
[[Image:Roemerlager bei masada.jpg|right|thumb|180px|Remnants of one of several legionary camps at Masada, just outside the circumvallation wall which can be seen next to it.]]
 
[[Image:Roemerlager bei masada.jpg|right|thumb|180px|Remnants of one of several legionary camps at Masada, just outside the circumvallation wall which can be seen next to it.]]
  
In 72, the Roman governor of Iudaea, [[Lucius Flavius Silva]], marched against Masada with the [[Roman legion]] [[Legio X Fretensis|X ''Fretensis'']] and laid siege to the fortress. After failed attempts to breach the wall, they built a [[circumvallation]] wall and then a [[Defensive wall|rampart]] against the western face of the plateau, using thousands of tons of stones and beaten earth. Josephus does not record any major attempts by the Zealots to counterattack the besiegers during this process, a significant difference from his accounts of other sieges against Jewish fortresses, suggesting that perhaps the Zealots lacked the equipment or skills to fight the Roman legion. Some historians also believe that Romans may have used Jewish [[Slavery in ancient Rome|slaves]] to build the rampart, whom the Zealots were reluctant to kill because of their beliefs.
+
In 72 C.E., the Roman governor of Iudaea, [[Lucius Flavius Silva]], marched against Masada with the [[Roman legion]] [[Legio X Fretensis|X ''Fretensis'']] and laid siege to the fortress. After failed attempts to breach the wall, they built a [[circumvallation]] wall and then a [[Defensive wall|rampart]] against the western face of the plateau, using thousands of tons of stones and beaten earth. Josephus does not record any major attempts by the Zealots to counterattack the besiegers during this process, a significant difference from his accounts of other sieges against Jewish fortresses, suggesting that perhaps the Zealots lacked the equipment or skills to fight the Roman legion. Some historians also believe that Romans may have used Jewish [[Slavery in ancient Rome|slaves]] to build the rampart, whom the Zealots were reluctant to kill because of their beliefs.
  
[[Image:MasadaRamp.jpg|left|thumb|180px|A shot of the ramp from the top.]]
+
[[Image:MasadaRamp.jpg|left|thumb|180px|A view of the ramp from the top.]]
  
The rampart was complete in the spring of 73, after approximately two to three months of siege, allowing the Romans to finally breach the wall of the fortress with a [[battering ram]] on April 16. When they entered the fortress, however, the Romans discovered that its approximately 1000 defenders had set all the buildings but the food storerooms ablaze and committed mass suicide rather than face certain capture or defeat by their enemies (which would probably have led to slavery or execution). Because [[Judaism]] strongly discourages [[suicide]], however, the defenders were reported to have drawn lots and slain each other in turn, down to the last man, who would be the only one to actually take his own life. The storerooms were apparently left standing to show that the defenders retained the ability to live and chose the time of their death over slavery. This account of the siege of Masada was related to Josephus by two women who survived the suicide by hiding inside a cistern along with five children and repeated Elazar ben Yair's final exortation to his followers, prior to the mass suicide, verbatim to the Romans. Josephus records that the besieged swore that while they could still do so, they would die free rather than enslaved; 'But certainly our hands are still at liberty, and have a sword in them; let them then be subservient to us in our glorious design; let us die before we become slaves under our eneimies, and let us go out of the world, together with our children and our wives, in a state of freedom.' <ref> Josephus, War with the Jews, Book VII, Chapter 8, section 7 [http://bible.christiansunite.com/jos.cgi?b=war7&c=8 War with the Jews] Retrieved September 7, 2007</ref>.  Josephus has Elazer admit that it has been wrong to resist Rome, and attribute the Jew's defeat to God's displeasure:
+
The rampart was complete in the spring of 73 C.E., after approximately two to three months of siege, allowing the Romans to finally breach the wall of the fortress with a [[battering ram]] on April 16. When they entered the fortress, however, the Romans discovered that its approximately one thousand defenders had set all the buildings but the food storerooms ablaze and committed mass suicide rather than face certain capture or defeat by their enemies (which would probably have led to slavery or execution). Because [[Judaism]] strongly discourages [[suicide]], however, the defenders were reported to have drawn lots and slain each other in turn, down to the last man, who would be the only one to actually take his own life. The storerooms were apparently left standing to show that the defenders retained the ability to live and chose the time of their death over slavery. This account of the siege of Masada was related to Josephus by two women who survived the suicide by hiding inside a cistern along with five children and repeated Elazar ben Yair's final exhortation to his followers, prior to the mass suicide, verbatim to the Romans. Josephus records that the besieged swore that while they could still do so, they would die free rather than enslaved:
  
:Wherefore, consider how God hath convinced us that our hopes were in vain, by bringing such distress upon us in the desperate state we are now in, and which is beyond all our expectations; for the nature of this fortress which was in itself unconquerable, hath not proved a means of our deliverance; and even while we have still great abundance of food, and a great quantity of arms, and other necessaries more than we want, we are openly deprived by God himself of all hope of deliverance; for that fire which was driven upon our enemies did not of its own accord turn back upon the wall which we had built; this was the effect of God's anger against us ... <ref>ibid</ref>Josephus descibes the deaths of 960 men, women and children.
+
<blockquote>But certainly our hands are still at liberty, and have a sword in them; let them then be subservient to us in our glorious design; let us die before we become slaves under our enemies, and let us go out of the world, together with our children and our wives, in a state of freedom.<ref> Josephus, [http://bible.christiansunite.com/jos.cgi?b=war7&c=8 The Wars of the Jews.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref></blockquote>
 +
 
 +
Josephus has Elazer admitting that it had been wrong to resist Rome, and attributing the Jew's defeat to God's displeasure:
 +
 
 +
<blockquote>Wherefore, consider how God hath convinced us that our hopes were in vain, by bringing such distress upon us in the desperate state we are now in, and which is beyond all our expectations; for the nature of this fortress which was in itself unconquerable, hath not proved a means of our deliverance; and even while we have still great abundance of food, and a great quantity of arms, and other necessaries more than we want, we are openly deprived by God himself of all hope of deliverance; for that fire which was driven upon our enemies did not of its own accord turn back upon the wall which we had built; this was the effect of God's anger against us….<ref> Josephus, [http://bible.christiansunite.com/jos.cgi?b=war7&c=8 The Wars of the Jews.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref></blockquote>
 +
 
 +
Josephus describes the deaths of 960 men, women, and children.
  
 
===Is Josephus Reliable?===
 
===Is Josephus Reliable?===
Josephus' account has been disputed on several grounds. Some doubt that Jews would have agreed to commit suicide, which is forbidden in Jewish law. Others do not think that the archeological evidence supports Josephus.<ref>The bodies of 32 people have been found at the site, in some cisterns and in a cave, apparently hiding, which casts doubt on the claim that all the defenders died in the suicide pact</ref>  Others suggest that the speech he attributed to Elazar at Masada, encouraging suicide, is a type of literary 'antilogos' to the speech against sucice which he has himself give, 'at Jotapata under similar circumstances' <ref>Cohen, Shaye "The Credibility of Josephus", from "Madada: Literary Tradition, Archeological Remains and the Credibility of Josephus", ''Journal of Jewish Studies'', XXXIII, 385-405 Spring-Autumn 1982 [http://members.aol.com/FLJOSEPHUS/archMasadaPBS.htm The Credibility of Josephus] Retrieved September 7, 2007</ref>Rather as Josephus himself survived the earlier suicide pact, Shaye (1982) suggests that what took place did not represent "unanimity of purpose and unity of action among the Sicarii in their final hours." What happened was probably much more haphazard with some Sicarii trying to hide and some taking their own lives. <ref>ibid</ref> However, it is equally doubtful that Josephus would have invented the entire story. He had no reason to do so. Thus, Cohen (1982) concluded:
+
Josephus's account has been disputed on several grounds. Some doubt that Jews would have agreed to commit suicide, which is forbidden in Jewish law. Others do not think that the archeological evidence supports Josephus. The bodies of 32 people have been found at the site, in some cisterns and in a cave, apparently hiding, which casts doubt on the claim that all the defenders died in the suicide pact. Others suggest that the speech he attributed to Elazar at Masada, encouraging suicide, is a type of literary “antilogos” to the speech against suicide which he has himself give, “at Jotapata under similar circumstances.”<ref>Cohen, Shaye, [http://members.aol.com/FLJOSEPHUS/archMasadaPBS.htm The Credibility of Josephus.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref> Rather as Josephus himself survived the earlier suicide pact, Cohen suggests that what took place did not represent "unanimity of purpose and unity of action among the Sicarii in their final hours." What happened was probably much more haphazard with some Sicarii trying to hide and some taking their own lives.<ref>Cohen, Shaye, [http://members.aol.com/FLJOSEPHUS/archMasadaPBS.htm The Credibility of Josephus.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref> However, it is equally doubtful that Josephus would have invented the entire story. He had no reason to do so. Thus, Cohen concluded:
  
:that Josephus attempted to be reasonably accurate in matters which were verifiable by Silva and the Romans. He refrained from inventing glorious military actions for the Sicarii, and, we may assume, had some basis in fact for the ascription of murder-suicide to them. At least some of the Sicarii killed themselves rather than face the Romans. This fact was exaggerated and embellished<ref>ibid</ref>
+
<blockquote>that Josephus attempted to be reasonably accurate in matters which were verifiable by Silva and the Romans. He refrained from inventing glorious military actions for the Sicarii, and, we may assume, had some basis in fact for the ascription of murder-suicide to them. At least some of the Sicarii killed themselves rather than face the Romans. This fact was exaggerated and embellished.<ref>Cohen, Shaye, [http://members.aol.com/FLJOSEPHUS/archMasadaPBS.htm The Credibility of Josephus.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref></blockquote>
  
Cohen (1998) suggests it likely that Josephus, in his efforts at apology for Jews and at rehabilitang their image in Roman eyes, "realized that the murder-suicide of some of the Sicarii at Masada would be far more dramatic and compelling if it became the murder-suicide of all the Sicarii" and so "sitting in his study in Rome" he "improved on his story"<ref>ibid</ref>
+
Cohen later suggests it likely that Josephus, in his efforts at apology for Jews and at rehabilitating their image in Roman eyes, "realized that the murder-suicide of some of the Sicarii at Masada would be far more dramatic and compelling if it became the murder-suicide of all the Sicarii" and so "sitting in his study in Rome" he "improved on his story."<ref>Cohen, Shaye, [http://members.aol.com/FLJOSEPHUS/archMasadaPBS.htm The Credibility of Josephus.] Retrieved October 5, 2007.</ref>
  
==Masada today==
+
==Masada Today==
 
[[Image:Israel-Massada Platform.jpg|thumbnail|150px|right|Platform access to the fortress]]
 
[[Image:Israel-Massada Platform.jpg|thumbnail|150px|right|Platform access to the fortress]]
 +
The site of Masada was identified in 1842 and extensively excavated in from 1963 to 1965 by an expedition led by Israeli archeologist [[Yigael Yadin]]. A pair of [[cable car]]s now carries those visitors who do not wish to climb the ancient Snake Path, now restored on the eastern side of the mountain (access via the Dead Sea road). The area remained largely untouched by humans or nature in the past two millennia, due to the location's remoteness from human habitation and its arid environment. The Roman ramp still stands on the western side and can be climbed on foot. Many of the ancient buildings were restored from their remnants, as were the wall-paintings of Herod's two main palaces, and the Roman-style [[bathhouse]]s that he built. The [[synagogue]], storehouses, and houses of the Jewish rebels were also found and restored. The meter-high circumvallation wall that the Romans built around Masada can be seen, together with 11 [[barracks]] for the Roman soldiers just outside this wall. Water cisterns two-thirds of the way up the cliff drain the nearby [[wadi]]s by an elaborate water system, which explains how the rebels managed to have enough water for such a long time. Other excavation took place after the [[Six-Day War]].
  
The site of Masada was identified in 1842 and extensively excavated in from 1963 to 1965 by an expedition led by Israeli archeologist [[Yigael Yadin]]. A pair of [[cable car]]s now carries those visitors who do not wish to climb the ancient Snake Path, now restored on the eastern side of the mountain (access via the Dead Sea road). The area remained largely untouched by humans or nature in the past two millennia, due to the location's remoteness from human habitation and its arid environment. The Roman ramp still stands on the western side and can be climbed on foot. Many of the ancient buildings were restored from their remnants, as were the wall-paintings of Herod's two main palaces, and the Roman-style [[bathhouse]]s that he built. The [[synagogue]], storehouses, and houses of the Jewish rebels were also found and restored. The meter-high circumvallation wall that the Romans built around Masada can be seen, together with eleven [[barracks]] for the Roman soldiers just outside this wall. Water cisterns two-thirds of the way up the cliff drain the nearby [[wadi]]s by an elaborate water system, which explains how the rebels managed to have enough water for such a long time.  Other excavation took place after the [[Six-Day War]].
+
==Legacy==
 +
When [[Moshe Dayan]] was the [[Israel Defense Forces]]' Chief of Staff, troops finishing their basic training started to regularly participate in swearing-in ceremonies at Masada, where participants swear an oath that "Masada shall never fall again." Hundreds of soldiers climb at night in rows along the Snake Road and then swear in with torches lighting the background. This was customary for troops of the [[Israeli Armor Corps]], the [[Givati Brigade]], and others. Marches to Masada are still popular in the IDF and a requirement for many units such as [[Nahal]].
  
==Legacy==
+
The Masada legacy was used in a similar context by the [[British Mandate of Palestine]], which conceived the [[Masada Plan]] to man defensive positions on [[Mount Carmel, Israel|Mount Carmel]] with [[Palmach]] fighters in order to stop [[Erwin Rommel|Erwin Rommel]]’s expected drive through [[Palestine]] in 1942. The plan was abandoned following Rommel's defeat at [[El Alamein]].  
The Masada legacy has been used in a similar context by the [[British Mandate of Palestine]], which planned the [[Masada plan]] to man defensive positions on [[Mount Carmel, Israel|Mount Carmel]] with [[Palmach]] fighters, in order to stop [[Erwin Rommel|Erwin Rommel's]] expected drive through [[Palestine]] in 1942. The plan was abandoned following Rommel's defeat at [[El Alamein]]. When [[Moshe Dayan]] was the [[Israel Defense Forces]]' Chief of Staff, troops finishing their [[Tironut]] started to regularly participate in swearing-in ceremonies in Masada, where participants swear the oath that ''"Masada shall never fall again."'' Hundreds of soldiers climb at night in rows through the Snake Road and then swear in with torches lighting the background. This was customary for troops of the [[Israeli Armor Corps]], the [[Givati Brigade]] and others.  Marches to Masada are still popular in the IDF and a requirement for many units such as [[nahal]].
 
  
 
Masada has been a [[UNESCO]] [[World Heritage Site]] since 2001. An audio-visual light show is presented nightly on the western side of the mountain (access by car from the [[Arad]] road or by foot, down the mountain via the Roman ramp path).
 
Masada has been a [[UNESCO]] [[World Heritage Site]] since 2001. An audio-visual light show is presented nightly on the western side of the mountain (access by car from the [[Arad]] road or by foot, down the mountain via the Roman ramp path).
 
Ben-Yehuda in "The Masada Myth" says that it reached its "most powerful form" in Palestine during [[World War II]], when it seemed possible that [[Erwin Rommel]]'s African Corps might invade.  He attributes the myth to secular Zionism, that needed tales that would re-inforce the notion of a bond between Eretz-Israel and the Jewish people. The myth helped "members of the Yishuv to face some truly formidable historical challenges" <ref>Ben-Yehuda, op cit.  The Yishuv were the Jewish settlers in Palestine. </ref>.  He suggests that since excavations at Masada have cast doubt on the Josephus version, it has "lost its sacred place in the secular Zionists pantheon of heroism". "Basically", he says, "Masada was transformed from a shrine of heroism and a sacred place for pilgrimage into a tourist attraction."
 
  
 
==Notes==
 
==Notes==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
 +
 
==References==
 
==References==
* Avi-Yonah, M. et al., ''Israel Exploration Journal'' 7, 1957, 1–160 (excavation report Masada)
+
* Avi-Yonah, M., et al. ''Israel Exploration Journal.'' 7. 1957. 1–160.
* Ben-Yehuda, Nachman. ''Sacrificing Truth: Archaeology and the Myth of Masada''. Amherst, N.Y.: Humanity Books, 2002ISBN 9781573929530  
+
* Ben-Yehuda, Nachman. ''Sacrificing Truth: Archaeology and the Myth of Masada.'' Amherst, N.Y.: Humanity Books. 2002. ISBN 9781573929530  
* Tamarin, Alfred H., and Flavius Josephus. ''Revolt in Judea, the Road to Masada: The Eyewitness Account by Flavius Josephus of the Roman Campaign against Judea, the Destruction of the Second Temple, and the Heroism of Masada''. New York: Galahad Books, 1975 ISBN 9780883652831  
+
* Tamarin, Alfred H., and Josephus, Flavius. ''Revolt in Judea, the Road to Masada: The Eyewitness Account by Flavius Josephus of the Roman Campaign against Judea, the Destruction of the Second Temple, and the Heroism of Masada.'' New York: Galahad Books. 1975. ISBN 9780883652831  
* Yadin, Yigael ''Masada: Herod's Fortress and the Zealots Last Stand '', NY: Welcome Rain, 1998 ISBN 9781566490337  
+
* Yadin, Yigael. ''Masada: Herod's Fortress and the Zealots Last Stand.'' NY: Welcome Rain. 1998. ISBN 9781566490337  
* Yadin, Yigael ''Israel Exploration Journal'' 15, 1965 (excavation report Masada)
+
* Yadin, Yigael. ''Israel Exploration Journal.'' 15. 1965.
* Yadin, Yigael. ''Bar-Kokhba; the Rediscovery of the Legendary Hero of the Last Jewish Revolt against Imperial Rome''. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1971 ISBN 9780297003458
+
* Yadin, Yigael. ''Bar-Kokhba; the Rediscovery of the Legendary Hero of the Last Jewish Revolt against Imperial Rome.'' London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. 1971. ISBN 9780297003458
 
 
==External links==
 
  
*[http://maps.google.com/maps?q=&ll=31.315278,35.353611&spn=0.005,0.005&t=k Masada by Google Maps] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
+
==External Links==
*[http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=238&letter=M ''Masada'' in the ''Jewish Encyclopedia''] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
+
All links retrieved November 7, 2022.
*[http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/religion/portrait/masada.html The credibility of Josephus] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
+
* Cohen, Shaye. [http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/religion/portrait/masada.html The credibility of Josephus.]  
*[http://www.livius.org/ja-jn/jewish_wars/jwar05.html LIVIUS article on Jewish Wars] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
+
* Gottheil, Richard, Jewish Encyclopedia. [http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=238&letter=M Masada.]  
*[http://whc.unesco.org/sites/1040.htm World Heritage Sites page] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
+
* UNESCO World Heritage Centre. [http://whc.unesco.org/sites/1040.htm Masada.]  
*[http://www.parks.org.il/ParksENG/company_card.php3?NewNameMade=46&from=116&CNumber=853401 Israel National Parks Authority page] Retrieved August 28, 2007.
 
  
 
{{credit|99611506}}
 
{{credit|99611506}}
  
 
[[Category:History]]
 
[[Category:History]]
 +
[[category:Archaeology]]

Latest revision as of 16:17, 7 November 2022


Siege of Masada
Part of First Jewish-Roman War
Massada Israel.jpg
Masada seen from the east
Date Late 72 C.E.–early 73 C.E.
Location Masada, in modern-day eastern Israel
Result Roman victory
Combatants
Jewish Zealots Roman Empire
Commanders
Elazar ben Ya'ir Lucius Flavius Silva
Strength
960 15,000
Casualties
953 Unknown, if any

Masada (a romanization of the Hebrew מצדה, Mitzada, from מצודה, metzuda, "fortress") is the name for a site of ancient palaces and fortifications in the South District of Israel on top of an isolated rock plateau on the eastern edge of the Judean Desert overlooking the Dead Sea. Masada became famous for its significance in the First Jewish-Roman War (Great Jewish Revolt), when a siege of the fortress by troops of the Roman Empire allegedly led to a mass suicide of the site's Jewish Sicarii or Zealot defenders when defeat became imminent.

Masada came to symbolize courage, patriotism, and self-defense for Jews. Its story has helped to counter the sentiment that Jews were always victims, always subject to other peoples' action, and never actors in their own right. In this view, the defenders of Masada resisted and died bravely, whether by their own hand or at the hands of others. Modern Israeli soldiers have often made vows to defend the State of Israel standing atop the fortress. The Masada story also helped to inspire the Warsaw Uprising during World War II, one of the first modern instances when Jews put aside their traditional submissive posture to take up heroic though futile resistance against an overwhelming oppressor.

Geography

The cliffs on the east edge of Masada are about 1,300 feet high, dropping off to the Dead Sea, and the cliffs on the west are about three hundred feet high; the natural approaches to the cliff top are very difficult. The top of the plateau is flat and rhomboid-shaped, about 1,800 by 900 feet. There was a casemate wall around the top of the plateau totaling 4,300 feet long and 12 feet thick with many towers, and the fortress included storehouses, barracks, an armory, the palace, and cisterns that were refilled by rainwater. Three narrow, winding paths led from below to fortified gates.

History

Dovecote at Masada, where ashes were probably stored—the openings have been shown to be too small for pigeons to fit.

According to Flavius Josephus, a first century Jewish Roman historian, Herod the Great fortified Masada between 37 and 31 B.C.E. as a refuge for himself in the event of a revolt. In 66 C.E., at the beginning of the First Jewish-Roman War (also called the Great Jewish Revolt) against the Roman Empire, a group of Jewish rebels called the Zealots (kana'im, "zealous ones," commanded by Elazar ben Ya'ir (who may have been the same person as Eleazar ben Simon), who objected to Roman rule of Judea (as the Roman province of Iudaea, its Latin name) took Masada from the Roman garrison stationed there. In 70 C.E., they were joined by additional Zealots and their families who were expelled from Jerusalem by the other Jews living there shortly before the destruction of Jerusalem (and the Second Temple), and for the next two years used Masada as their base for raiding and harassing Roman and Jewish settlements alike.

Remnants of one of several legionary camps at Masada, just outside the circumvallation wall which can be seen next to it.

In 72 C.E., the Roman governor of Iudaea, Lucius Flavius Silva, marched against Masada with the Roman legion X Fretensis and laid siege to the fortress. After failed attempts to breach the wall, they built a circumvallation wall and then a rampart against the western face of the plateau, using thousands of tons of stones and beaten earth. Josephus does not record any major attempts by the Zealots to counterattack the besiegers during this process, a significant difference from his accounts of other sieges against Jewish fortresses, suggesting that perhaps the Zealots lacked the equipment or skills to fight the Roman legion. Some historians also believe that Romans may have used Jewish slaves to build the rampart, whom the Zealots were reluctant to kill because of their beliefs.

A view of the ramp from the top.

The rampart was complete in the spring of 73 C.E., after approximately two to three months of siege, allowing the Romans to finally breach the wall of the fortress with a battering ram on April 16. When they entered the fortress, however, the Romans discovered that its approximately one thousand defenders had set all the buildings but the food storerooms ablaze and committed mass suicide rather than face certain capture or defeat by their enemies (which would probably have led to slavery or execution). Because Judaism strongly discourages suicide, however, the defenders were reported to have drawn lots and slain each other in turn, down to the last man, who would be the only one to actually take his own life. The storerooms were apparently left standing to show that the defenders retained the ability to live and chose the time of their death over slavery. This account of the siege of Masada was related to Josephus by two women who survived the suicide by hiding inside a cistern along with five children and repeated Elazar ben Yair's final exhortation to his followers, prior to the mass suicide, verbatim to the Romans. Josephus records that the besieged swore that while they could still do so, they would die free rather than enslaved:

But certainly our hands are still at liberty, and have a sword in them; let them then be subservient to us in our glorious design; let us die before we become slaves under our enemies, and let us go out of the world, together with our children and our wives, in a state of freedom.[1]

Josephus has Elazer admitting that it had been wrong to resist Rome, and attributing the Jew's defeat to God's displeasure:

Wherefore, consider how God hath convinced us that our hopes were in vain, by bringing such distress upon us in the desperate state we are now in, and which is beyond all our expectations; for the nature of this fortress which was in itself unconquerable, hath not proved a means of our deliverance; and even while we have still great abundance of food, and a great quantity of arms, and other necessaries more than we want, we are openly deprived by God himself of all hope of deliverance; for that fire which was driven upon our enemies did not of its own accord turn back upon the wall which we had built; this was the effect of God's anger against us….[2]

Josephus describes the deaths of 960 men, women, and children.

Is Josephus Reliable?

Josephus's account has been disputed on several grounds. Some doubt that Jews would have agreed to commit suicide, which is forbidden in Jewish law. Others do not think that the archeological evidence supports Josephus. The bodies of 32 people have been found at the site, in some cisterns and in a cave, apparently hiding, which casts doubt on the claim that all the defenders died in the suicide pact. Others suggest that the speech he attributed to Elazar at Masada, encouraging suicide, is a type of literary “antilogos” to the speech against suicide which he has himself give, “at Jotapata under similar circumstances.”[3] Rather as Josephus himself survived the earlier suicide pact, Cohen suggests that what took place did not represent "unanimity of purpose and unity of action among the Sicarii in their final hours." What happened was probably much more haphazard with some Sicarii trying to hide and some taking their own lives.[4] However, it is equally doubtful that Josephus would have invented the entire story. He had no reason to do so. Thus, Cohen concluded:

that Josephus attempted to be reasonably accurate in matters which were verifiable by Silva and the Romans. He refrained from inventing glorious military actions for the Sicarii, and, we may assume, had some basis in fact for the ascription of murder-suicide to them. At least some of the Sicarii killed themselves rather than face the Romans. This fact was exaggerated and embellished.[5]

Cohen later suggests it likely that Josephus, in his efforts at apology for Jews and at rehabilitating their image in Roman eyes, "realized that the murder-suicide of some of the Sicarii at Masada would be far more dramatic and compelling if it became the murder-suicide of all the Sicarii" and so "sitting in his study in Rome" he "improved on his story."[6]

Masada Today

Platform access to the fortress

The site of Masada was identified in 1842 and extensively excavated in from 1963 to 1965 by an expedition led by Israeli archeologist Yigael Yadin. A pair of cable cars now carries those visitors who do not wish to climb the ancient Snake Path, now restored on the eastern side of the mountain (access via the Dead Sea road). The area remained largely untouched by humans or nature in the past two millennia, due to the location's remoteness from human habitation and its arid environment. The Roman ramp still stands on the western side and can be climbed on foot. Many of the ancient buildings were restored from their remnants, as were the wall-paintings of Herod's two main palaces, and the Roman-style bathhouses that he built. The synagogue, storehouses, and houses of the Jewish rebels were also found and restored. The meter-high circumvallation wall that the Romans built around Masada can be seen, together with 11 barracks for the Roman soldiers just outside this wall. Water cisterns two-thirds of the way up the cliff drain the nearby wadis by an elaborate water system, which explains how the rebels managed to have enough water for such a long time. Other excavation took place after the Six-Day War.

Legacy

When Moshe Dayan was the Israel Defense Forces' Chief of Staff, troops finishing their basic training started to regularly participate in swearing-in ceremonies at Masada, where participants swear an oath that "Masada shall never fall again." Hundreds of soldiers climb at night in rows along the Snake Road and then swear in with torches lighting the background. This was customary for troops of the Israeli Armor Corps, the Givati Brigade, and others. Marches to Masada are still popular in the IDF and a requirement for many units such as Nahal.

The Masada legacy was used in a similar context by the British Mandate of Palestine, which conceived the Masada Plan to man defensive positions on Mount Carmel with Palmach fighters in order to stop Erwin Rommel’s expected drive through Palestine in 1942. The plan was abandoned following Rommel's defeat at El Alamein.

Masada has been a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 2001. An audio-visual light show is presented nightly on the western side of the mountain (access by car from the Arad road or by foot, down the mountain via the Roman ramp path).

Notes

  1. Josephus, The Wars of the Jews. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  2. Josephus, The Wars of the Jews. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  3. Cohen, Shaye, The Credibility of Josephus. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  4. Cohen, Shaye, The Credibility of Josephus. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  5. Cohen, Shaye, The Credibility of Josephus. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
  6. Cohen, Shaye, The Credibility of Josephus. Retrieved October 5, 2007.

References
ISBN links support NWE through referral fees

  • Avi-Yonah, M., et al. Israel Exploration Journal. 7. 1957. 1–160.
  • Ben-Yehuda, Nachman. Sacrificing Truth: Archaeology and the Myth of Masada. Amherst, N.Y.: Humanity Books. 2002. ISBN 9781573929530
  • Tamarin, Alfred H., and Josephus, Flavius. Revolt in Judea, the Road to Masada: The Eyewitness Account by Flavius Josephus of the Roman Campaign against Judea, the Destruction of the Second Temple, and the Heroism of Masada. New York: Galahad Books. 1975. ISBN 9780883652831
  • Yadin, Yigael. Masada: Herod's Fortress and the Zealots Last Stand. NY: Welcome Rain. 1998. ISBN 9781566490337
  • Yadin, Yigael. Israel Exploration Journal. 15. 1965.
  • Yadin, Yigael. Bar-Kokhba; the Rediscovery of the Legendary Hero of the Last Jewish Revolt against Imperial Rome. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. 1971. ISBN 9780297003458

External Links

All links retrieved November 7, 2022.

Credits

New World Encyclopedia writers and editors rewrote and completed the Wikipedia article in accordance with New World Encyclopedia standards. This article abides by terms of the Creative Commons CC-by-sa 3.0 License (CC-by-sa), which may be used and disseminated with proper attribution. Credit is due under the terms of this license that can reference both the New World Encyclopedia contributors and the selfless volunteer contributors of the Wikimedia Foundation. To cite this article click here for a list of acceptable citing formats.The history of earlier contributions by wikipedians is accessible to researchers here:

The history of this article since it was imported to New World Encyclopedia:

Note: Some restrictions may apply to use of individual images which are separately licensed.